Aisles / Returns and exchanges
Let customers start returns and exchanges themselves and keep revenue with exchanges. We priced 3 apps at three store sizes and checked each against the same eight rules. What drives the bill here: returns a month.
Prices checked October 8, 2026.
| # | App | Checks | 300 orders | 2,000 orders | 10,000 orders |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |  AfterShip ReturnsEasy pick | 7/8 checks passed | $24 | $109 | Quote |
| 2 |  ReturnGOGood, with caveats | 5/8 checks passed | $147 | $259.50 | $927 |
| 3 |  LoopRead the fine print | 4/8 checks passed | $155 | Quote | Quote |
Monthly cost on the cheapest plan that covers the store, billed monthly, from public prices. "Quote" means the developer only prices that size on request.
Small and mid-size stores that want a low-cost returns portal from a Built for Shopify app should start here. The catch: key rules and fraud tools sit on the $119 Premium plan, and at 500 or more returns a month every plan is priced by quote.
Fails: prices public at every size. Full review
Stores with steady return volume that want exchange-first returns and fast, hands-on support are the fit. The catch: there is no free plan, and the cheapest plan costs $147 a month.
Fails: built for shopify, 500+ merchant reviews, works with shopify flow. Full review
Mid-size and larger brands that want exchanges, fraud rules and Shopify Flow in one returns tool are the fit. The catch: paid plans start at $155 a month, and the price for bigger stores is set in a contract.
Fails: prices public at every size, built for shopify, rated 4.7 or higher, 500+ merchant reviews. Full review
AfterShip Returns ranks first here: it passes 7 of our eight checks and costs $109 a month at 2,000 orders. Small and mid-size stores that want a low-cost returns portal from a Built for Shopify app should start here. The catch: key rules and fraud tools sit on the $119 Premium plan, and at 500 or more returns a month every plan is priced by quote.
At 2,000 orders a month, AfterShip Returns costs the least of the apps we priced: $109 a month on Essentials. The order changes at other sizes; use the table above or price your whole stack.
By how many of our eight checks each app passes, then by the monthly bill for a growing store. No developer can pay for a place.